The short answer: online, almost every time — 98% of consumers research online before hiring a home services business, and 35% now start that discovery in AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini rather than a traditional search bar. Word of mouth still opens the door (61% of homeowners trust it), but the referral gets googled before anyone picks up the phone. Here's what the 2026 search journey looks like — and where Ontario contractors fall out of it.

Do homeowners still find contractors through referrals?

Yes — but a referral is the start of the search now, not the end of it. A Leaf Home survey conducted with Morning Consult found 61% of homeowners trust word-of-mouth recommendations when choosing a provider. The same survey explains why they double-check them: nearly 70% worry about unreliable contractors, and 41% say they've been deceived by a service provider during a home project. Trust is the whole game in this industry, and homeowners have learned not to extend it on a neighbour's say-so alone.

So the referred name gets searched. ACHR News reports 91% of homeowners rely on online reviews before picking a contractor — which means a glowing recommendation from a brother-in-law in Burlington still dies if the Google listing behind it shows six reviews and a photo from 2019. Referrals haven't been replaced. They've been given a verification step, and plenty of good GTA contractors quietly fail it.

Is Google still the first stop — or is it ChatGPT?

Both, and the balance is shifting faster than most trades realize. Similarweb data reported by CallRail shows 35% of consumers now use AI tools like ChatGPT and Google Gemini at the discovery stage — against just 13.6% who turn to traditional search first. The homeowner behaviour is easy to picture: instead of typing "deck builder St. Catharines" and wading through ads, they ask an assistant "who should I get to build a deck in St. Catharines, and what should it cost?" and get three names back.

Which three names come back is not random. AI assistants pull from the same signals as local search — reviews and ratings, consistent business information across the web, and service pages that actually answer questions in plain language. That's why we build contractor websites around the questions homeowners ask, not brochure copy: a page that plainly answers "how much does a kitchen renovation cost in Hamilton?" is exactly the kind of source an AI assistant cites, and exactly what a referred homeowner wants to find when they verify you.

The Discovery Shift
35% vs 13.6%

35% of consumers now use AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini at the discovery stage — versus just 13.6% who turn to traditional search first (Similarweb). The contractor search journey is moving before Google even loads.

How much do reviews actually decide?

More than any other single factor. BrightLocal's consumer research has 81% of consumers relying on Google Reviews to decide whether to use a business, and 77% checking two or more review sites before choosing. They're not just counting stars, either — 88% would use a business that replies to all of its reviews, versus just 47% for one that doesn't respond at all. The reply is the proof that someone competent answers the phone.

Reviews also move the price homeowners will accept. A Housecall Pro survey found 72% of homeowners would pay up to 10% more for a contractor with a stronger service reputation. On a $60,000 Niagara home addition, that's a $6,000 premium earned by a Google profile — which makes the twenty minutes a week spent requesting and answering reviews some of the best-paid work in your company. And review-checking has spread beyond Google: BrightLocal finds 34% of consumers use Instagram and 23% use TikTok to evaluate local businesses, which is where job-site content from a managed social presence quietly closes homeowners who never fill out a form.

What makes a homeowner actually pick you?

Speed and clarity, mostly — because the shortlist is shorter than you think. Clever's research found 42% of homeowners compare only two quotes, and just 15.6% compare four or more. You're not competing against every contractor in the region; you're competing to be one of the first two or three names that respond.

Then the clock takes over. Housecall Pro found 97% of homeowners say response speed and transparent pricing influence which pro they hire, and Jobber's data shows 41% of jobs booked online come in after hours — evenings and weekends, when nobody in a Vaughan office is watching the inbox. CallRail's own data adds that 60% of customers prefer to call a business after finding it online. Put those together and the 2026 loss pattern is obvious: the homeowner finds you at 9 p.m., calls at lunch, hits voicemail, and the second name on the list wins a job you never knew you were in.

What should an Ontario contractor do about it?

Work the journey in the order homeowners actually travel it. First, make the verification step easy to pass: an active Google Business Profile with fresh reviews, every review answered, photos from this season's jobs. Second, make your website answer real questions with real numbers — that's what ranks, what AI assistants cite, and what referred homeowners need to see. Third, show the work where homeowners already scroll: before-and-afters and job-site video on Instagram and Facebook do the trust-building that stock photography can't, which is the core of our construction marketing engagements across Toronto, Hamilton and Niagara. Fourth, fix response speed — after-hours booking, auto-replies, a human on the phone fast — because 97% of homeowners are scoring you on it.

None of this is complicated. It's just operational discipline applied to a search journey that moved online while a lot of good contractors were busy building things. The ones who adapt own their local market; the ones who don't become the unverifiable referral.

Frequently asked questions

Do homeowners still find contractors through word of mouth?

Yes — 61% of homeowners trust word-of-mouth recommendations when choosing a provider. But a referral is now the start of the search, not the end of it: 91% of homeowners check online reviews before picking a contractor, so a recommended name with a thin Google profile still loses the job.

Are homeowners really using ChatGPT to find contractors?

Increasingly, yes. Similarweb data shows 35% of consumers now use AI tools like ChatGPT and Google Gemini at the discovery stage, versus just 13.6% who turn to traditional search first. AI assistants recommend contractors based on reviews, service pages and consistent business information — the same signals that drive local SEO.

How many quotes do homeowners actually get?

Fewer than most contractors think. Clever's research found 42% of homeowners compare only two quotes, and just 15.6% compare four or more. If you're not in a homeowner's first two or three calls, the job is usually gone before you ever hear about it.

What matters more to homeowners: price or reputation?

Reputation carries real dollar value. A Housecall Pro survey found 72% of homeowners would pay up to 10% more for a contractor with a stronger service reputation, and 97% say response speed and transparent pricing influence which pro they hire. Cheapest quote rarely wins on its own.

Sources: CallRail, 31 Home Services Marketing Statistics for 2026 (citing BrightLocal, Similarweb, LocalIQ, Housecall Pro, Jobber); Improveit 360, Major Shifts in How Homeowners Choose Contractors (citing ACHR News, Leaf Home/Morning Consult, Housecall Pro, Clever).